Whether ballet causes bunions is genuinely unresolved, and we are not going to pretend otherwise
You will find hallux valgus reported in 36.8%, 40.0% and 54.9% of
dancers depending on the study. That looks damning until you read
further: a radiographic study reported that hallux valgus angles in
both active professional dancers and retired dancers were similar to
non-dancers, and that continuing in ballet did not develop the
deformity.
A 2011 review of pointe biomechanics put it bluntly: despite the
unnatural loading, no study had shown that dancing on pointe raises
injury risk. We have not found one since that settles it.
There is one small intervention study in dancers — four weeks of foot
exercise in thirteen elite adolescent dancesport athletes who already
had hallux valgus, which reduced the angle and improved their
self-reported outcome. It is a pilot, in teenagers, in a discipline
that trains in heels.
Why this entry exists
It would be easy to quote the 54.9% and stop. Much of that prevalence
data comes from dancers aged 8 to 16, the studies use different
measurement methods, and at least one radiographic study points the
other way entirely. We would rather you knew that than bought
something because of a number we cherry-picked.